ShadowTalk AI vs Proton Lumo — encrypted AI, compared honestly

    The short answer

    Proton Lumo encrypts stored chat history with zero-access encryption — but inference is cloud-only: Lumo's published security model documents the server decrypting your prompt to process it, and you need an account and a live connection. ShadowTalk AI adds the missing half — an on-device model with zero network egress — plus E2EE Private Mode (AES-256-GCM) and BYOK across 16+ providers.

    Proton's privacy pedigree is real, and we credit it below. But the encrypted-AI camp has a structural gap: encryption around storage while the cloud still sees the prompt. This page maps exactly where the two products differ — including the limits we ship in public and they don't have to admit because their defaults are different.

    Proton Lumo vs ShadowTalk AI, dimension by dimension

    DimensionShadowTalk AIProton Lumo
    Offline useYes — on-device inference, zero network egress after model downloadNo — cloud-only; no connection, no answers
    Where your prompt is processedOn your device (WebGPU mode) or at your chosen provider via BYOK — direct browser-to-provider, no ShadowTalk proxyProton servers — Lumo's security model documents decrypting the prompt server-side to answer
    Account requiredNo — guests chat immediatelyYes — Proton account
    Stored-history encryptionPrivate Mode: end-to-end AES-256-GCM, keys derived on your device, non-extractable and memory-onlyZero-access encryption of stored history
    Sync across devicesYes — including offline-queued chats on reconnectYes — synced encrypted history
    Model choiceOn-device models + 16+ providers via BYOKProton's served models only
    Trust pedigreeIndependent product built in public; honest limits published (default chats stored server-side; free shared mode transits the server)A decade of audited privacy credentials, Swiss jurisdiction, institutional reputation

    Landscape checked Nov 2026. Every checkmark is a shipped, verifiable behavior — not a roadmap item.

    Where Proton Lumo wins

    • Institutional trust: audits, Swiss legal protection and a ten-year track record you can point a compliance team at
    • Polish and support of a mature privacy company behind it
    • A name enterprises already recognize

    The verdict

    Lumo is the strongest brand in encrypted AI — and it still needs the internet, an account, and Proton's servers seeing your prompt in cleartext to answer it. ShadowTalk covers the intersection Lumo can't reach: on-device inference that never touches a network, offline chat that queues and syncs, and encryption you hold the keys to. If institutional pedigree is your top requirement, Lumo is a fine choice; if 'nothing sees my prompt' is the requirement, that's the on-device tier.

    One honest asymmetry to weigh: Lumo's zero-access storage is its default; ShadowTalk's end-to-end encryption is opt-in Private Mode, and we document exactly what the defaults do instead. ShadowTalk is the first AI chat in a browser that works offline and syncs when you're back — encrypted AI that also survives the tunnel.

    Frequently asked questions

    Free to use — no account, no card.

    Works offline. Syncs when you're back. Your keys, your models, your chats.

    Try encrypted + offline AI — free